Why I Quit Making Beauty Judgements (Even Positive Ones)

Written by

*This may be a new idea for some of you, and some may not agree. I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments section!*

A while back, I spent some time as a volunteer, helping take care of a bunch of kids in a nursery-type setting. As I played with these sweet little babies and toddlers (they were all delightful), I noticed a few children that I thought were especially adorable.

One day, another volunteer struck up a conversation with me. “Look at little Liza!” she said. “I cannot get over how cute she is!” [Name changed. I don’t remember her real name.]

I turned my gaze to Liza. Honestly, I was at a loss for words. This was not a child I had noticed as being one of the outstanding “cute ones.” She had not made my list, and I didn’t have an enthusiastic agreement on my tongue, because I had failed to notice her much.

I wasn’t going to contradict a statement like this, because, of course, all children are cute. So instead, I slowly nodded in agreement, and began watching the little girl with new eyes. I tried to see her as this volunteer did.

With this renewed vision, I soon recognized her unique beauty, and was quite struck by it. Knowing that someone else thought she was special changed my perception of her (or perhaps lack of perception, in this case).

Then it hit me. God views each person as special and beautiful. Their features are His handiwork. Their image is a reflection of His. 

The way the volunteer admired Liza, which caused me to see her differently, is the same way God admires each of His creations.

When God created mankind, He said this was, “very good.” He makes each one on purpose.

As a scanned the room, a sense of instant conviction washed over me for the “beauty judgements” I had made among these precious little people. I saw the pridefulness within my own heart that lead me to think this was my determination to make!

I realized in sorrow that with each “have” I had identified in my own mind (regardless of whether or not I commented), I was inadvertently categorizing many other children as “have not’s.”

A positive “judgement” was not much better than a negative one at the heart level… Not any better.

Although this potentially forgettable experience happened a long time ago, the resulting reflection and effects it brought into my life linger.

They’ve changed how I talk and think about people.

Now, when I look at children, or anyone, I enjoy and appreciate their unique features. I choose to see that God has made them beautiful and valuable, not “better” or “worse” than one another (as society or culture would influence us to believe).

I will still comment that a child is cute, but I no longer do this in a way that singles him or her out from a crowd, insinuating that the others are not so much.

Rather, I take a heart-position of praise to God for how He made a child (or grown up) as an individual, with equal readiness to do the same for every other one. I appreciate his or her unique features and looks. No comparison needed.


And celebrities on TV? I’ve decided not to make beauty judgements about them either. Because, while they may never know or be directly effected by my opinion of them, it does affect those around me –not to mention my own heart.

SIDE NOTE: Can we mar the body God has given us through poor choices or sin or neglectfulness or lack of self-control?

Yes, I think we can. I believe we are responsible for caring for our bodies and cultivating the beauty God has put there for His glory. This is not what I’m talking about. Rather, I’m talking about appreciating the way God made a person –the things about us that aren’t ours for the changing.

So often, the lens through which we judge and evaluate beauty is faulty. It is a culturally-invented thing. What one culture considers beautiful, another does not –all around the world and throughout history. Think about African tribal women who intentionally elongate their necks. Or the Chinese tradition for women to bind their toes back until they fall off in pursuit of smaller feet.

Beauty is culturally-determined. But there is a deeper truth about beauty.

Each person is God’s workmanship: an overflow of HIs loving, creative, relational nature –an overflow of His goodness, and a perfect fit to His eternal plans and purposes.

So, what would it mean for us to loosen our grip on our own beauty judgements? –to consider that we might not be the best judge, and to choose to see people as God does?

How would it change our view of others? Of ourselves? How would it change our children’s view of themselves as they watch us recognize and celebrate the goodness of what God has made, rather than judge and rank it?

Let’s resolve to choose to see the beauty in each person —not in comparison to someone else –but rather in light of God’s glory displayed in them.


New to this community? Start here, friend.

You Don't Have to be a Victim of Your Schedule and Home

Get this FREE 5-step guide to simplify your life so that you can focus on what actually matters.

You will also join 4,100+ other subscribers to receive weekly encouragement to see eternity in your home and to live in its light.

Life is too short and God is too good to live distracted.

accent accent

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.


  1. Jaimie E. says:

    This is a really great point. We tend to forget that conceptualizations of beauty are culturally conditioned. I have a friend in her early 50’s who is an international speaker who used to tell me about speaking in India. Those women LOVE to show some belly, and apparently the flabbier and bigger your belly is as an older woman, the better: it means you had lots of babies (needless to say, my friend was quite self-conscious about having to speak in a church with her belly peeking out).

    Another point that is related — and relevant to Christian women — is that modesty is also culturally conditioned. It’d be great to get your thoughts on that, too. My husband and I live in the Middle East and it’s sometimes hard to adjust to varying views of what’s considered modest from one country to another. I end up feeling like I don’t really know my own convictions. Maybe it’s just a Romans 14 kinda thing. Sometimes I can’t wait for heaven when we’ll all just have white robes and don’t need to worry about style and modesty and beauty etc etc. But I’m sure that as we seek to portray God’s glory in even these details of life, we can learn something of His character and desires for us.

    • Such great thoughts Jaimie! Thank you for sharing! I have often thought this about modesty as well. It’s completely hinged on our cultural context. We have freedom to dress in such away that points attention to Christ and not to ourselves, whatever that means for where we find ourselves.

  2. Akeelah says:

    Well-said, Katie! I agree that we can definitely affect the hearts of those around us by making these “judgments.” I have been convicted about this for quite some time (especially about celebrities, in talking about them with friends). We were all created in HIS image, so who am I to judge what is “better” or “worse.” I totally agree with Eliza on this one: Comparison is the thief of joy. We are women should really be mindful to not compare ourselves as it demeans what the Lord has deemed “very good!”

    • Yes! I agree Akeelah! It’s funny how I sometimes thing it’s okay to judge or gossip about celebrities. Really, I don’t think our proximity to the target changes the sin at all, considering it is a heart issue in me.

      Good thoughts!

  3. Nataliya says:

    Well said! I’ve been working on this but from a different perspective. Not comparing myself to others and Keeping my identity in Christ. For the Lord looks at the heart. The culture tells us many things, it’s easy to loose sight of the things that really matter. I really like what you said and how we should be teaching and living that out for our children. We truly we are each uniquely made in the image of God! Thank you for sharing!

  4. Marilyn Seavers says:

    I enjoyed reading your thoughts. The idea of beauty is so deeply ingrained in us, even though it does vary in different cultures and time periods! We are all so influenced by it and by our culture…even our churches that it can be almost an unconscious thing. How many times have you seen churches promoting a “celebrity” type athlete or other very attractive speaker? You very seldom see a promotion to come hear this quiet, older, thin, heavy ( pick one) person who is going to speak about what he has learned about God. The person may speak, but there won’t be the big build up! I know God sees us all as beautiful because he sees the heart and doesn’t look at our outward appearance which is always also beautiful to Him because he created us and loves us. What a great insight you were given in your day caring for a bunch of little kiddos.

  5. Eliza says:

    Thank you for putting into words a feeling that has been on my heart for some time. I used to be (and still can be when I am not being intentional about it!) really bad at comparing people, usually to myself, and either finding them or me wanting in some way. I have now realised that this is a really bad way to live, after all, comparison is the thief of joy, so I am trying to be intentional about seeing the good where ever I am looking, and not worrying about the. ‘More than’ or ‘less than’. I need to find the joy in where God has me right now, not base my joy on whether I am doing better than someone else. He has given us all ‘talents’ based on His infinite wisdom, it is up to us to use those ‘talents’ to bring Him glory, to the best of our ability!

    • “comparison is the thief of joy,” I love that! Wow, great thoughts Eliza. Thank you for so much for sharing! This is such a great word –I’m going to give this some thought.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *